Rogue’s Gallery: Pirate Ballads, Sea Songs, and Chanteys

November 26, 2009 · Filed Under Songs 

roguesgalleryIt must have seemed like a good idea at the time.   The story goes that Johnny Depp, fresh from playing Captain Jack Sparrow in the highly popular if extremely uneven “Pirates of the Caribbean” movies decided to get his rock star friends together to make a CD of pirate songs and sea chanties.  What could be bad?

The answer to the question, “what could be bad?” regarding Rogue’s Gallery, the two CD set that resulted,  is regrettably –  most of it.  The entire CD may not be execrable garbage, but the majority of it is.  The only really good news is that you do not have to actually buy it to decide for yourself.   By the magic of Youtube, many of the CD cuts are on-line, some in live performance.  Amazon also provides 30 second previews of all 43 songs on the album.

How could so many talented musicians and singers create such noisome noise?  I think most of them just never got the memo.  Most don’t seem to understand what sea chanties or sea songs are all about.    When Nick Cave, the punk rocker, takes the slyly obscene, Fire Down Below, adds punk rock  instrumentation, an out of tune chorus and shouts “And all you mother f__ckers, if you lead a life of sin,” well, shall we say that the charm is lost?  Or when Martha Wainwright sings Lowlands, her voice is fine but is so overwhelmed by the orchestration that the song seems beside the point.  (Most sailors did not travel with full orchestras.)  Likewise, Bono’s  version of A Dying Sailor To His Shipmates is 4 minutes,48 seconds long, of which about 3 minutes is Bono moaning along with the orchestra. And on and on it goes.

To be fair, Richard Thompson, Sting and John C. Riley get it more or less right.  Their songs feature limited accompaniment, straight-forward singing and robust choruses.   I particularly like John C. Riley’s “Fathom the Bowl.”   Nevertheless, these three stalwart singers can’t make up for all the rockstar preening and over orchestration.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Comments

4 Responses to “Rogue’s Gallery: Pirate Ballads, Sea Songs, and Chanteys”

  1. Andy on November 26th, 2009 11:22 pm

    Thanks for the review. I’d seen this album, but was not impressed with the short tracks provided on Amazon.

    Here are some that I have liked:

    Roast Beef of Old England (Traditional Sailor Songs) by Jerry Bryant and Starboard Mess

    Classic Maritime Music>/i> from Smithsonian Folkways Recordings

    Sea Music by Dan Zanes Festival Five Folk
    — nominally a kid’s CD, but drawing songs from a number of unexpected traditions

  2. Rick on November 27th, 2009 9:33 am

    They all sound like good recommendations. Thanks Andy.

  3. lame-e-lema on November 30th, 2009 7:25 am

    oh, come on. the songs are not that bad. i bought the cd when it was released and still love it. really, even the “punk rock” tracks are fun to listen. and nick cave doing sea chanteys – what did you expect? i strongly recommend the cd. if you can live with the songs not being all original anymore, go and buy it. it´s worth it.

  4. Rick on November 30th, 2009 4:29 pm

    Whatever music you like is great. Maybe I am being too much of a purist. Then again between Bono’s moaning, Cage’s shouting and all the over orchestration and waling guitars, it didn’t work for me. And Baby Gramps and Lou Reed singing shanties? Who though that was a good idea? I am an old fan of Lou Reed but a shanty singer, he is not.

Leave a Reply




Video of the Moment

HMS Surprise and Star of India

Also featuring the Californian
and the Lynx

To be notified of blog updates
enter your email address:

woman enhancement high blood pressure symptom blood pressure medication new arthritis drug prevention and osteoporosis buy nirdosh depression and anxiety celebrex generic preventing hair loss anxiety medication side effects ambien overdose medication tricor famotidine 20mg does prosolution work nexium effects xanax for depression weight loss cheap buy clonazepam online lasix cheap pepcid viagra muscle pain in leg elevated blood sugar viagra buying online generic lasix Levitra Online Pharmacy high blood pressure med viagra overdose information nexium water pills online xanax alternative treatment arthritis preventing hair loss treatment hepatitis c weight loss diets cialis online levitra prescription condom sales relief foot pain health asthma increasing a womans sex drive selling pet products bisoprolol 5 mg hair loss treatment prices carnitine vasotec vpxl pill pain in right side rhinitis treatment treatment for vomiting generic for viagra exercise osteoporosis safe healthy dog food levitra results building your body prescription lipitor treatment parkinsons disease cure for throat infection list of blood pressure medication diuretic medicines products back pain dog health care nexium generic relieve upper back pain Viagra, Levitra And Cialis real valium sildenafil online no prescription cheap viagra buy xanax no prescription calcium chanel blocker cialis without a prescription treatments for hair loss buy levitra online with fast delivery generic online ultram weight loss medicine care of cat viagra generic cheap femara drug buspar online Real Levitra Online generic valtrex generic revatio zantac interaction cialis viagra cialis levitra cure acne medication for irritable bowel syndrome buy viagra soft flavored order prozac xanax free consultation brain cancer treatment viagra cialis cheap cheap tramadol cod drugs for swelling treatments for myasthenia gravis buy beconase cardura buy lovastatin order on line medicine without prescriptions buy didronel how to gain muscle mass fast quitting zyban buy mefenamic acid ativan medication zantac interaction dog medicines tramadol for sale cialis buy cialis bupropion about soma lipitor drug delivery tramadol natural cure for constipation long term ambien antibiotics online medication for myasthenia gravis carisoprodol medication antibiotics for cat treatment high blood pressure online viagra in the us generic revatio prozac depression cat bowel generic for xanax parasite medications how to build muscle cheap estrace lexapro prescription nolvadex 10mg hypnotherapy for health cheap phentermine without a prescription bone loss treatments phentermine online no rx pain medications generic side effects levitra cialis viagra chlamydia medication dosage flu care treatment of human parasites dental teeth whitening phentermine next day treating urinary tract infection women taking viagra natural pet products buy simplicef pain control system vitamins store diflucan dosage estradiol pill cialis online prescription cheap fast valium strong erection the cialis cheapest cialis online online paxil herpes drug do male enhancement pills work seroquel for depression drugs for swelling buy cialis tadalafil allegra order stress drug get antibiotics buy levitra viagra cialis cheap carnitine citalopram 20mg stopping snoring buy glucosamine sulfate discount pet products effexor and tramadol buy cheap amoxil without prescription order birth control online weight loss products order shingles treatment free smoking treatment back pain meds without prescriptions online medication aspirin online imitrex acessrx top 10 weight loss supplement stop premature ejaculation prostate cancer treatment muscle pain minocin online buy phentermine without prescription buy xanax online erectile dysfunction medication information antibiotics to buy ambien in canada total health discount blood pressure treatment drugs endep ambien and side effects symptoms high blood pressure blood pressure symptoms adhd and medications buy generic viagra weight loss products for women back pain products osteoporosis treating control of pain allergy treatments excersises to increase bust top ten acne products protonix generic what is ativan asthma information pepcid ordering cialis online how to loss weight ambien health about cialis natural antibiotic anti-biotic acne cream viagra online pharmacy generika levitra teeth whitening uk withdrawal symptoms lorazepam allegra skin swelling zoloft buy new antibiotic drug vardenafil effectiveness anti wrinkles cialis levitra viagra heart failure viagra for her weight loss diet natural cholesterol control pills for acne cat infections pharmacy drug prices effects of zoloft generic pravachol viagra buy online buy glyset premature ejaculation cure voltaren tablets coumadin medication cialis canada pharmacy acne skin care products how to prevent hair loss clindamycin drug clonazepam .5mg vs valium cat urinary tract disease viagra tablet drug stores acne face medication bronchitis remedy causes of chest pain pepcid dog bowel problems coumadin side effects adhd in children antibiotic properties Cialas On Line Buy order coq10 high blood calcium levels buy prandin buy periactin dog products online buspar antifungal shampoo allergy meds citalopram pregnancy order pheromones acne cream natural acne remedy treatment for aids generic lasix sleep help valium uk claritin dose mexico viagra relieve lower back pain stop herpes chronic pain drug levitra on-line cheap baclofen normal blood pressure buy pain meds now headache treatment chronic pain drug carb blocker diet arthritis management valium maximum dosage viagra with out prescription generic for toprol bladder control women where can i buy phentermine online female body building program weight loss support group online cancer drug buy cialis online viagra permanent hair loss viagra online purchase alprazolam stomach pain relief pharmacy drug prices fast weight loss tips how to buy diet pills cures for cold sores phentermine without perscription buy tentex royal general health and medical side effects soma buy augmentin cat's health where to buy cialis lisinopril dosing vardenafil effectiveness online weight loss cialis buy on line viagra cialis online weight loss pill fat blocker approved natural breast enhancer best weight loss solutions weight loss diet pill weight loss doctor diflucan dosage weight loss after preganancy prevention of heart attack diet weight loss women enhancement depression therapy cheap revatio buy medication on line buy zyrtec online buying generic cialis online purchase viagra mojo maxx but cialis online progesterone clomid zyrtec online buy drugs without prescription buy cha de bugre Order Viagra Online In Germany albuterol proventil buy folic acid delivery tramadol oral fluconazole alcoholism treatment program insomnia sleep problems hair loss natural treatment wellbutrin cymbalta antibiotics diarrhea what are beta blockers skin psoriasis erectile dysfunctions metronidazole dose bupropion alternative therapy for rheumatoid arthritis teen birth control depression self help viagra buying online viagra in britain vitamine b1 about cialis dog health problem how to increase bust prices soft tab cialis left side pain erectile dysfunction medications attention deficit hyperactive disorder ciprofloxacin 500mg allergy hives cheap xanax online generic pravachol ultram information claritin pill tips for weight loss the flu order flagyl improve sexual confidence wrinkle cures high blood pressures medications maxalt dosage itching ointment causes for high blood pressure side effects ativan healthy pet treats how to prevent high blood pressure drug loratadine avandamet help sleeping drugs lower blood pressure viagra order cialis without rx furosemide buy prescription drugs on line buy phentermine without prescription viagra purchase symptoms of fluid retention flu vaccine health asthma perscription drugs general health tips how long does valium last zyrtec online healthy and natural weight loss products celexa buy buy pain medicine on-line vitamins health penis enlargement result blood pressure control levitra cialis compare cialis cialis information medicine for constipation healthy pet treats buy imipramine online how to use clomid healthcare pharmacy treatment for bone loss online prescription pills latest treatment for osteoporosis famvir dose zoloft order control bleeding pills for acne buy acto plus generic viagra generic drugs lower heart rate osteoporosis treatment zyrtec for nolvadex 20mg natural muscle and joint health dog and cat care acceptable blood pressure antibiotic herbs Purchase Cialis Online Without Prescription cialis consultation cheap viagra canada flu treatment alternative diet drug online ambien online erectile dysfunctions blood pressure high acne cure pills vitamins for women rhinocort spray where to buy cheap phentermine online cheap soma acne remedies weight loss doctor online cialis prescription online buy viagra order viagra buy singulair increase male sex drive buy cha de bugre