The Tale of the Mermaid Pods – Carnival Awarded $24 million in lawsuit with Rolls Royce

This week Carnival Cruise Lines was awarded $24 million in a lawsuit with Rolls Royce related to the repeated failure of the  “Mermaid Pods” on Carnival’s Cunard Line ship, Queen Mary 2. Last year about this time Royal Caribbean Cruise Lines reached a $65 million settlement with Rolls Royce over Mermaid pods on its ships.

Mermaid pods are either the best or the worst idea to hit the cruise industry in the last few decades.   “Podded” propulsion is intended to replace conventional shafting rudders and stern thrusters. A “pod” is a strut extending from the hull of a ship with an electric motor inside, driving a propeller.

Pods are often designed to rotate, thus performing the job of both the rudder and a stern thruster.  The podwas intended the cruise captain’s dream in that it was designed to provide efficient slow speed maneuvering and a simper propulsion system over all.   Rolls Royce marketed their “Mermaid pods” and sold quite a few to Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Lines.  A competitor, ABB sold their “Azipods” to Norwegian Cruise Lines among others.

The problem is that the propellers which drive the ship are directing all their thrust through a rotating bearing  on the pod which also happens to steer the ship.  If this bearing fails, the ship loses the pod as both a propulsion system and as a rudder.  Most ships have either two or four pods. Often two pods are fixed (non-rotating.)  Royal Caribbean had  Mermaid Pods installed on their subsidiary Celebrity Cruise Line Millennium class ships and soon were taking ships out of service and cancelling cruises because of Mermaid pod bearing failures.

Notwithstanding the problems that the cruise lines have had with pod propulsion, it still remains the system of choice in cruise ship new building.  The new Cunard liners Queen Elizabeth and Queen Victoria both have Azipod propulsion.

This entry was posted in Lore of the Sea. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to The Tale of the Mermaid Pods – Carnival Awarded $24 million in lawsuit with Rolls Royce

  1. Bryan Inder says:

    Does the new Queen Elizabeth have Rolls-Royce Azipod Propulsion?
    With thanks
    Bryan Inder
    Past Federal President
    Rolls-Royce Owners’ Club of Australia
    [I travelled recently on Queen Elizabeth and am writing an article for our club]

  2. Rick says:

    There are two principal competitors in the pod propulsion business – Rolls Royce and ABB. Rolls Royce makes Mermaid pods and ABB makes Azipods. Both have had problems but the RR Mermaid pods have been the most unreliable.

    The Queen Elizabeth and the Queen Victoria have ABB Azipods not Rolls Royce Mermaid pods.

  3. Pingback: Little things that make you happy :) - Page 123

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>