The Drunk Guy, the Stolen Skiff, the Ferry Terminal & the Illusion of Security

Last Thursday evening, a man described as being extremely drunk, stole a skiff in Bayonne, NJ, and drove it across New York harbor to Staten Island. He docked the boat in a slip at the St. George Staten Island Ferry Terminal, walked up the gangway and disappeared. The problem is that the ferry terminal docks are considered to be a “secure area” and the drunken man walked right through several restricted areas to make his escape. Alarms bells, literally and figuratively, have been going off ever since.

The Staten Island Ferry is the single busiest ferry route in the United States with an average daily ridership of around 65,000 passengers. Last year it set a record for carrying almost 24 million people.

How serious was the security breach? Some are invoking the 2000 USS Cole bombing in Yemen, where suicide bombers drove a small boat loaded with explosives into the side of the destroyer killing 17 and seriously damaging the ship. They ask what would have happened if instead of a drunken boater, the skiff was loaded with explosives and driven by terrorists.  Thomas Checchi writing for the Staten Island Advance demands action. He writes: “The case revealed gaping holes in ferry security that the Coast Guard, the NYPD, and the DOT need to closely examine and fix — immediately.”

On the other hand in the very busy and congested harbor, there are limits to what can be done. The Coast Guard reports that there are occasional security breaches but that the public should not be concerned.  Gary Wexler, of Elite Investigations, is quoted by CBS News: “I don’t think the public should be concerned at all. There are approximately 250 sensitive spots along the harbor. I think protocols were implemented. If they weren’t then the public should be, but clearly, all were followed. There was an immediate notification, an immediate response.”

The skiff was reported to be stolen from Ken’s Booming and Boat Service in Bayonne. Police are still on the lookout for the intoxicated thief. 

The challenge in a highly congested harbor like New York is how to balance access with safety and security. Sadly, there are no easy answers.

 

This entry was posted in Current, Lore of the Sea and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to The Drunk Guy, the Stolen Skiff, the Ferry Terminal & the Illusion of Security

  1. Peter Wright says:

    I am so glad that protocols were “implepented.” Rest easy New York.

  2. Bob says:

    Bayonne is in New Jersey

  3. Rick Spilman says:

    Thanks. That was a particularly stupid typo. Fixed it.

  4. Willy says:

    The problem with secure areas? They only work to keep people from going one way. Yet really have no control of if some one is already on the wrong side.

  5. Peter Wright says:

    Rick, the “impleplented” came from the video, 1:00, I don’t think you can fix that! Rest easy New Jersey. (Thanks Bob.)

  6. ws says:

    How Could This Happen,
    And where is the usually asleep Main Stream Media..
    MAESEC 1!
    Bring your fat tire Schwinn bicycle on the SI Ferry and they Treat you like Bin Laden..
    Thank You, Old Salt Blog, and Rick Spilman!

  7. Doug Bostrom says:

    Let alone while sitting at the dock, it’s a little hard to imagine how ferries can be protected from any and all traffic during their operating schedule, short of being accompanied by a pair of armed escort craft at all times while under way. And let’s be honest: we’re not willing to pay for that (considering all the other mitigations we “can’t afford”).

    As well, hyper-vigilance itself can be problematic. An incident comes to mind (personally familiar) concerning clearing a clogged strainer with a less than fully experienced person necessarily left to steer, bringing us a wee bit too close to a Washington State ferry. Would be a sadly unnecessary thing to die in a hail of bullets because of a simple error of that kind.

  8. Doug’s got it. The idea that we’re going to perfectly protect every single thing in the country all the time from some nebulous terrorist threat is asinine. The idea that we should even try is a horrible waste of resources. Cheer up! The world is very safe, New York even more so.

  9. ws says:

    A drunk Captain didn’t raise any suspicions?

  10. Rick Spilman says:

    More a drunk guy who stole a boat than a drunk captain.

  11. Jean-Pierre Declemy says:

    Marinas and other shore side facilities would all agree that it is always harder to secure from seaward. Fences and gates don’t float.